News:
- Waxon has an open trading dispute. He has been dishonored until further notice.
- Added a new paragraph to this thread regarding issues with traders not providing feedback.
- If you have 51+ feedback, you get a banner link. PM me with the URL.
Notice: Latest update on 11/17 on page 145.
I will try to update this at least once every two weeks (I've been failing at this lately).
The format of this list is as follows:
[Trader Name] [Number of successful trades] [Number of failed trades][State | Country if not USA]
When providing feedback, just reply to this post with "[Trader Name] +1" where X is the number of successful trades you would like to record. Most of the time, it's +1. If you would like to leave additional information, such as the quality of the trader's shipping method, timeliness, etc., go ahead.
For failed trades, I recommend you contact your trading partner to sort things out. It may take a couple weeks for the shipment to arrive (take note of where your trader resides) so please be patient. If things are settled to the satisfaction of both parties, then there's nothing to report. If you cannot get in contact with your trader, or if there is trouble with getting a satisfactory settlement, then please reply to this thread with a small anecdote of the incident. Also, please PM me so that I may quickly update the list to notify the community.
NEW: If a trader does not provide feedback to you via this thread, then I cannot give you a positive feedback. A screenshot of the PMs or emails of the trade would not suffice as they could be doctored. This policy is to ensure the integrity of this feedback system. You could contact me instead and I could try to get in touch with the trader. Additionally, you could rescind/withhold your feedback. However, you could not give negative feedback (those are reserved for truly unsuccessful trades).
If you have any questions regarding this thread, feel free to PM me. As I have tons of PMs daily, please name your message "Rating Thread" so that it doesn't get lost in the clutter.
RANK 6
(101+ successful trades)
Kysuke 191 0 [Connecticut]
Naecabon 328 0 [Massachusetts]
RANK 5
(51-100 successful trades, get your banner posted)
hawaiidude 98 0 [Hawaii]
PythonPimp 64 0
TS 70 0 [Nevada]
Violence 70 0 [California]
RANK 4
(20-50 successful trades)
Arnold Rimmer 47 0
Calcos 33 0
chart1710 38 0
ChristofRG 28 0
cloaknpoke 36 0
COW13OY 26 0
Darthgnome 29 0
Empekat 36 0
FemmGamer 27 0
Flight2039Down 39 0
Fytalia 30 0
Gorsham 44 0
Grishnaar 25 0
halfmoonhaloeffect 54 0
HoodieDM 26 0
KillerTofu209 41 0 [California]
Kusig 23 0
Machomp 22 0
Ming 24 0 [Connecticut] (formerly Superming)
MulletMania 21 0
Ome75 22 0
Phaladusss 24 0
Predatory 24 0
Purdge 30 0
Rexob85 37 0
Saucedoryan 41 0
scm2117 41 0 [New York]
sicariusdracus 29 0 [Kansas]
Treidum (note) 22 0 [Canada]
William Rose 31 0
RANK 3
(10-20 successful trades)
Akkim 19 0
cPOP 19 0
DvogtQB 14 0
Erdagon 18 0
Evicerate 14 0
flamejackal 11 0 [New Jersey]
Gavrel 14 0
gilrandur 14 0
iluvjing 11 0
intheUSA 15 0
Jinna 14 0
jordandelandgow 11 0 [Canada]
Joshsteltzer 11 0
KaijinSH 12 0
kl37 13 0
louisianapadawan 19 0 [Louisiana]
mchayes 11 0
Mestopholies 12 0
mgs112 14 0
mujrim 17 0
muzicman23 11 1 - [06/27/08]- reported by scm2117 (p.122)
Nighthowl 12 0
Nikko1 11 0
palpat 14 0
PaulLange 12 0
Penek 16 0 [Russia]
QuickdrawGC 11 0
Scorponok 15 0
Shadowlands 20 0
Shalmar 18 0
slednecker2 15 0
StaticEel 18 0
Tetsuye00 20 0
TinMan354 12 0
toniocity 14 0 [California]
Tors 20 0
tvsnick 11 0
Ungelosh 12 0
waretix 11 0
xuldinga 20 0
RANK 2
(6-10 successful trades)
Ackis 8 0 [Canada]
Ademaro 6 0
Aetherian 7 0
anothefoo 9 0
Apattrick75 6 0
avatar7 6 0
Bashymashy 6 0
BruenoB 6 0
BunklorE 9 0 [New York]
cagn 9 0
Ceefuhs 6 0
Chris103190 7 0
contractkiller 6 0
DarkJodo 16 0
Demonfae 10 0
dkBlindside 10 0
druidwarlock 8 0
eightblocks 13 0
Ekhanh 6 0
Frosted 8 0
gambit300 6 0
Gimpyaggie 8 0
Gnam 6 0
htownaggie 7 0
Jacimo 8 1 [United Kingdom] [07/16/07] - reported by Violence (p. 40)
Jbwms713 6 0
Jedion 9 0
JoeJoe88 10 0
Jtheman20 6 0
Jspruill 8 0
jules 16 0
Kalscension 6 0
KhayanCastro 6 0
Kommakozzy 7 0
Longshanks 9 0
Madysin 6 0
Malgamus 10 0
Maquis 6 0
meggamann41 8 0
Mirena 8 0
MPS76248 9 0
MrChrisT 8 0
Mujibar 7 0
mungoape 7 0
myemfar 8 0
Myztery 8 0
nadalcameron 10 0
nalanthi 8 0
NMCMCM 8 0
Oowafas 10 0
Orphus 9 0
pantsmessiah 10 0
parabellum 6 0
Rapidstrike666 6 0
Relanor 8 0
richardpau 9 0
Rick99gtp 6 0
Scissors 7 0
shelk 8 0
SMumps 10 0
snarfxsnarf87 7 0
Spectre121 6 0
Stoopid 9 0
sweeperpaints 8 0
Tarwyn00 10 0
Thechauffeur 6 0
thekcfin 6 0
tigerfire 8 0
tscarty 9 0
Tubbyfu 8 0
Vestax159 8 0
Viseres 7 0
Vexor 10 0
Wadark 9 0
WOWTCGLOOT 10 0 [California]
Wraithor 7 0
xcgblargy 9 0
RANK 1
(1-5 successful trades)
1647991 1 0
1825615 5 0
Aaric 2 0 [Canada]
aaron 1 0
Adgabjo 1 0
Aganym 1 0
Aggballer77 1 0
alanelf 2 0
Ahtiven 2 0
Alainmathieu27 4 0
AliciaN 4 0
Altec42Lansing 1 0
AJAnimosity 1 0
Amneziak 2 0
antiflagrev 1 0
Aragorn 2 0
Ashrahm981 1 0
asterisk 5 0
asanders31 1 0
Attackofthe 1 0
apenny4mrkenny 2 0
AUStarwars 2 0 [Canada]
Aviston 2 0
barlafumble 2 0
baseplyr78 2 0
Basilis88 2 0
Battleherd 2 0
Bayushishade 4 0 [Canada]
Belch 5 0
benharparino 1 0
BennyLava 2 0
beregarii 1 0
bhancov 1 0
biggiy2c 2 0
bigpoppame 1 0
Bjarn 1 0
bluemonick 1 0
blurred_reality 1 0
Bodra 1 0
booclarke 2 0
Borow 1 0
Braveheart14 1 0
Breakmark 2 0
Br0kenbones 1 0
Cabelim 4 0 [Brazil]
cacabojo926 1 0
CalQdeX 4 0
Carbonite 1 0
Cardmastergames 2 0
Carlaa 2 0
Carnage17 1 0
cbequette 4 0
ccgscards 1 0
Cerlyn 1 0
Chrisbarefoot 1 0
ciadragon 1 0
ciel0 2 0
Ck 1 0
Cloudfrog 4 0
Clovtar 1 0
Constable 4 0
crashtard 2 0
Creona 5 0
crodant 3 0
crownofroyal578 1 0
Dagent48 1 0
daisho 3 0
Dan 1 0
DaneJuros 4 0
Danzeva 1 0
DarkGage 2 0
DarthMarburg 1 0
datorz 1 0
davemm 2 0
DeathKnightMike 3 0
Deuceswild 3 0
DHKnecht 2 0
diabolic 1 0
DigitalDWR 1 0
djbhobbys 1 0
DJSamurai37 1 0
DoctorMeatus 1 0
dojihiko 1 0
doomofthepeople 1 0
doulos 5 0
Dozer4 1 0
drazticmeazres 3 0
Dregeric 2 0
DrStrangeFOSD 1 0
Druthu 1 0
DustyH 1 0
dtrenh10 4 0
dyemid32 1 0
Ellsof 1 0
ElPolloDiablo 4 0
Entreri23 1 0
EntropySJ 1 0
EonarPriest 2 0
Erandona 2 0
Eric 1 0
esotericenigma 1 0
externalpunk 4 0
FabionoMonte 4 0
Faragorn 1 0
FarmerGiles 2 0
Fearreaper 2 0
Fibus 3 0 [New York]
fidg3t 1 0
figrinbob 1 0
FlameSkyeFox 3 0
Freudinio 3 0
frdrake 3 0
Gadgetron 2 0
Game260 1 0
George1972 5 0
Gerams76 3 0
Ghostridergo 3 0
GMUNYIFan 1 0
Goldenjew 1 0
GPFault 3 0
GrassRoots 1 0
Grayja 3 0
gregconway 1 0
Gromph 11 0
Gwath 5 0
HarrisonFisk 3 0
Heavyhitter40 2 0
herbnl1fe 2 0
Hikariu 1 0
hordeoverseer 2 0
Houjix 2 0
hun3er 5 0
IAMJOBOSKI 1 0
Ibrah 8 0
IceHot 1 0
icehouse1986 1 0
IchigoFTK 5 0
Illusion 1 0
IknowWonki 1 0
Imackid 1 0
in3d 2 0
jacckk 1 0
Jace Darkwulf 1 0
jalmynar 3 0
jamminj606 5 0
janjetina 3 0 [Croatia]
Jarko531 2 0
JediLuke 1 0
jeffvmahar 2 0
jemp 1 0
jeremysimpson 4 0
jimmy3guts 1 0
Jinxed8602 5 0
Joseay 3 0
Joybell563 5 0
JPF1603 3 0
JPhill02 2 0
jpmoney23 4 0
jssmatt 1 0
Jubilex 2 0
Judas85 1 0
Jusnah 4 0
jwagoner 5 0
jwcarlyle 5 0
Kagaden 1 0
Kalfuzi 4 0
Kamadrin 2 0
Kaminaayato 1 0
karedis 2 0
Kearar 3 0
KeithofAK 1 0
Kelnath42 2 0
Ketricel 1 0
Kharagh 3 0
Khorne 1 0
Kingzzk 3 0 [Singapore]
kisszilla 3 0
Kitsune311 2 0
kittenceleste 3 0
Klev 4 0
Knivestgn 4 0
Korinthe 1 0
Kremlangerli 5 0
Kunadiso 2 0
Kupalski 4 0
Lex007 1 0
lexusEBD 3 0
Lightmasa 2 0
lilman42413 4 0
llamachime 4 0
Lohku 1 0
lzxuan 3 0
MacDaddyG 4 0
Maclem279 2 0
Madfizzicks 1 0
madjinn 1 0
Magimaster12 4 0
Mancmatt 1 0
Mandor1784 2 0
MangaBoy722 1 0
Marauxus 1 0
Markim 5 0 [Brazil]
markditmars 2 0
masterchiefspiff 1 0
Masterring 1 0
Masterdeamon 5 0
Masterwindu 1 0
McLovinJue 1 0
MechaFan 1 0
Mec7z 2 0
Meepits 1 0
Meldince 1 0
Midellas 3 0
Mier101294 1 0
Mkarac 2 0
mmabigshow 3 0
MoonkinDruid 2 0
Mornan 3 0
Mozu 3 0
MyBodyasaSheild 1 0
Nashun 1 0
Nightchill 3 0
Nimos 4 0
NirvanaFan 1 0
Ntong 2 0
nothingatall544 1 0
nukeedge 1 0
NY518 1 0
o78Chance 2 0 [California]
omgmypony 3 0
OON978 1 0
OpFor 1 0
Onslaught_Master 2 0
Pacerdefault 1 0
paddyo90 1 0
Panosbob 1 0
pascal9922 4 0
PhilltheThrill 1 0
Pursestrings 1 0
Putrifaction 3 0
Racolten 2 0 [Australia]
Ragefall 1 0
ralin664 4 0
Rceschmidt 2 0
rendaddy 2 0
RenoNinjaTurk 1 0
Robodudezero 3 0
rokallnite13 1 0
rokanos99 1 0
rsaylors 1 0
sainten1 1 0
SamurajSK 1 0
SamuelGrey 3 0
saphiesaphire 1 0
SarMnem 5 0
SeanConnery 5 0
Seehawk 1 0
sengurruk 2 0
Senlowe 2 0
seraphimscall 1 0
shaehawk 2 0
ShamusMG 1 0
ShiningEntity 2 0 [England]
Silkvelvet 1 0
SilverChampion 1 0
Sini5ter 1 0
Skeden 1 0
Skinnerti 1 0
skotos 1 0
Skyshark23 1 0
Slayzernaught 1 0
Snowblind 5 0
solusek 1 0
Spacelion 5 0
Splinter5150 1 0
stabbe 1 0
starcrafter 2 0
Starcrafter117 3 0
stealthbaz 1 0
Stelshadow 3 0
Strikeratt 1 0
Str00dles 1 0
Sutrase 3 0
Swift1984 1 0
Targrath 1 0
tetradd 1 0
theevilisback 1 0
TheIGreatIOne 1 0
tiber55 4 0
Tiliandra 2 0
ThanhNguyen14 1 0
TheBrandonOne 1 0
TheFourthHorseman 3 0
TheOnly2006 2 0
ThePiousFlea 1 0
ThePollock 1 0
theshadowdeath 1 0
TheTruePhoenix 1 0
ThramFalcox 4 0
Tokhuah 4 0
Tsaroth 1 0
thepurplesmurf 2 0
Turboduck01 1 0
Twylite 1 0
Tzina 5 0
underdawgs 1 0
Utilityblade 1 0
Vampirelord54 2 0
VikingNoah 3 0
Vicarious 1 0
Viracocha 1 0
visualdeity 1 0
vighter 1 0
Vinceisg0d 3 0
Vorple99 5 0
Warstunner 2 0
wheresfobos82 2 0
wowccgelmo 1 0
wongyl83 1 0
wrw712 3 0
Warmasterrajuk 1 0
WoWtcgmetamart 1 0
Wowzzzzz 1 0
Wrathofheaven 1 0
Xereos 4 0
xdevilsxrosex 2 0
Xithaj 1 0
xNarchoNx 1 0
xthexpunisherx 1 0
yepgoodness 1 0
Yindotrunks 1 0
zakarum 1 0
Zebulan 4 0
DISHONORED TRADER
1203482 1 1 - [08/25/07] - reported by SeligCree (p.48)
Angelicninja25 0 1 - [01/19/07]
Apogs 0 1 - [10/14/07] - reported by sweeperpaints (p.58)
BlueHeron 0 1 - [07/25/07] - reported by klave
Brandeni 1 1 - [03/01/07] - 1 trade since
BubbenMcPoonSnatch 3 1 - [11/26/07] - reported by Kharagh (p.71)
Execus 0 1 - [12/28/06]
(p.45), anothefoo (p.89)
deslo 14 2 - [05/24/08] reported by Kysuke, Darthgnome
FacelessTyrant 1 1 - [09/30/07] - reported by Hawaiidude (p.56)
Fight With Tools / BrokenTech / Exiledvoid 0 4 - [12/28/06] - reported by 1647991 (p.43), ungolesh (p.44), Relanor Gaiddan 6 2 - [05/23/07] - reported by ekhanh
Greger22 6 3 - [12/28/06] - 5 trades since dishonored
hammer1021 0 1 [01/25/07]
Heuwdarogue 1 2 [08/25/07] - reported by Racolten
hitman3o3 8 1 [05/25/08] - reported by mps76248 (p.115)
Irishwarlock 25 2 - [05/20/08] - reported by jordandelandgow (p.111), nikko1 (p.123)
Joker784 0 1 - [03/01/07]
knightstale 9 1 - [03/13/07] by Kalscension
Lunatic High 0 1 - [12/08/06]
MagicQuebec (aka Treidum?) 16 5 [Canada] - reported by Fibus (p.57), KaijinSH (p.60), Grassroots (p.63), ungelosh (p.63), and Shadowlands (p.65)
Megapwnage 5 1 - [02/18/08]- reported by Erdagon (p.93)
murphDAWG69 3 1 - reported by Naecabon (p.66)
OrkWarlok 0 1 - [06/05/07]- reported by jeffvmahar
Prospekt 0 1 - [02/18/08]- reported by anothefoo (p.89)
Rogued 4 7 - [02/18/08]- reported by DarkJodo (p.92), Frosted, Cabelim, TinMan354, Basilis88 (p.93), Hitman3o3, KBub604
Rogue07 13 2 - [05/23/07] - reported by lilman42413, Calcos (p.20)
rbowen87 0 1 - [05/07/07]- reported by Kysuke
slenaas 0 1 - [05/07/07]- reported by Relanor
urialblackblade 0 2 - [06/20/07]- reported by tvsnick (p.126), Kysuke (p.129)
Waxon 28 1- [11/17/08]- reported by DarkJodo (p.144)
Xathrax 0 1 - [06/20/07]- reported by vexor (p.28)
Zombiehell666 0 1 - [01/22/07]
For your reference, Sicarius' old rating thread is here.