Upper Deck Entertainment Forums

Upper Deck Entertainment Forums
Welcome to Upper Deck Entertainment Forums Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Ban List discussion

Last post 07-26-2008, 6:34 AM by HybridHero. 147 replies.
Page 2 of 10 (148 items)   < Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next > ... Last »
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  02-21-2008, 2:53 PM 1042114 in reply to 1042110

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1493920:
    1071932:

    Hmm...So let's see....Cyber-Stein was banned mid-format but that was a christmas present if I remember correctly. Are we getting an Easter present this year?



    After it ruins the entire Summer of Yu-Gi-Oh? Traveling becomes 10x more realistic for most people in the Summer. Its a joke if they expect average people to pay 150$ and drive 6 hours to play in a 5 hour SJC where 65% of the decks end the game within 2 turns.
    That's if you plan on playing. I don't see a reason anymore if most duels are just 1-3 turns.
  •  02-21-2008, 2:57 PM 1042120 in reply to 1042114

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1071932:
    1493920:
    1071932:

    Hmm...So let's see....Cyber-Stein was banned mid-format but that was a christmas present if I remember correctly. Are we getting an Easter present this year?



    After it ruins the entire Summer of Yu-Gi-Oh? Traveling becomes 10x more realistic for most people in the Summer. Its a joke if they expect average people to pay 150$ and drive 6 hours to play in a 5 hour SJC where 65% of the decks end the game within 2 turns.
    That's if you plan on playing. I don't see a reason anymore if most duels are just 1-3 turns.


    Ya besides just explosion, DAD decks, DDT, and Plants can all generally otk in the first 3 turns as well.
  •  02-21-2008, 2:58 PM 1042122 in reply to 1042120

    Re: Ban List discussion

    I got to watch a "Darklord Zerato" deck tear people up at this last weekend's events here.  FTKs abound...

    Simon Key

    Yugioh! TCG Rules Knowledge Level 3
    WoW TCG Rules Knowledge Level 2
    WoW Minis Rules Knowledge Level 1
    Player Management Level 3
    Tournament Organizer Level 1
  •  02-21-2008, 2:59 PM 1042124 in reply to 1042107

    Re: Ban List discussion

    Your more likely to mill out your Magical Explosions with the way these builds are.  And when you try to get them back only to see those Crowed as well, then what?

    And even if you are able to get it off the first time, do you really think you're likely to get it off again against good players?  This is just like the "outrage" over how dominant the Demise decks would be.  Well let's see, they flamed out in the first SJC they were featured in, won the next one, and then faded back into obscurity thereafter because people were ready on how to beat them so it became nothing more than the tech deck or 2 that might have made it to the top again.

    It's almost amusing to see all the kneejerk reactions when changes come and people think "the format is ruined... because nothing was done about <whatever> this deck type will dominate" and then when the game was actually played... well gee, guess things didn't work as well as everyone thought. 

  •  02-21-2008, 3:01 PM 1042126 in reply to 1042120

    Re: Ban List discussion

    Costa Mesa is going to get its 1000 people due to the prizes but come Columbus I see there being a 30% attendence drop off from last year and that thrend continuing until either something is done or we see <100 people SJCs in Hawaii and Missuouri and ultimately <100 SJCs being the average.
  •  02-21-2008, 3:03 PM 1042132 in reply to 1042126

    Re: Ban List discussion

    Great now UDE wants EVERY ONE to main DD crow
    The Reaper will Feast on your Soul!!!!!!!!!
  •  02-21-2008, 3:07 PM 1042140 in reply to 1042124

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1858158:

    Your more likely to mill out your Magical Explosions with the way these builds are.  And when you try to get them back only to see those Crowed as well, then what?

    And even if you are able to get it off the first time, do you really think you're likely to get it off again against good players?  This is just like the "outrage" over how dominant the Demise decks would be.  Well let's see, they flamed out in the first SJC they were featured in, won the next one, and then faded back into obscurity thereafter because people were ready on how to beat them so it became nothing more than the tech deck or 2 that might have made it to the top again.

    It's almost amusing to see all the kneejerk reactions when changes come and people think "the format is ruined... because nothing was done about <whatever> this deck type will dominate" and then when the game was actually played... well gee, guess things didn't work as well as everyone thought. 



    Optimist much? GOOD ME FTK are nothing but Draw. Look at the list. 3 Hand Destruction, 3 Allure, 3 D.Draw, 3 Trade-In, and Diamond Dude. That's a total of 24 Cards draw possible a turn. Include in that DMOC, 30 Draws, Include in that the 3 Valleys, that's 36 tops, include Dimension Fusion to return the valleys, that's 45. A MAX of 45 draws in ONE turn. The odds of NOT getting 2 ME are low. And even WITHOUT it, I have seen Dogmas summoned on opening turn replacing the need for a 2nd, I've seen ME Aggro FTK, the potential is truly endless on what will happen to you.

    Sorry for being a OPTIMIST at what WILL happen, but you're overrating Crow's capabilities.

    Level 1 YGO Rules Knowledge Judge
    Come join Northern Duel Academy (View profile for Link)
  •  02-21-2008, 3:12 PM 1042150 in reply to 1042132

    Re: Ban List discussion

    this list stinks, It is a piece of lemon! It is a joke! UDE is kidding!

    It is a crazy list... ban call of  the haunted but limit monster reborn? in which mind does it go?

    It is a copy of the OCG list, and it seems ude does not think that  Japan and the TCG are not the same worlds concerning to this game. the way of playing is totally different!

    madness !!!!


    Jinzo is reslly the best!!!
  •  02-21-2008, 3:14 PM 1042157 in reply to 1042150

    Re: Ban List discussion

    Magical Explosion should never ever ever ever ever ever ever main deck Diamond Dude.


    Lets set up my SECOND TURN when I am going to FIRST Turn Kill
  •  02-21-2008, 3:16 PM 1042161 in reply to 1042140

    Re: Ban List discussion

    And losing Dimension Fusion is another way to kill things off if you're relying on the Valleys.  I'm not saying the deck isn't good (since it's been played before to moderate success), but even with the changes, when push comes to shove, I don't see someone being consistantly lucky enough to pull it off let's see... 30 times to win Costa Mesa?  Figuring on 10 rounds on day 1, and then 5 more on day 2.  The fact that they are cutting to the top 32 is the only thing that might give it more of a fighting chance.  And personally I think the best players will be able to stop it over a 3 round match more often than you think it will be gotten off.
  •  02-21-2008, 3:16 PM 1042163 in reply to 1042157

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1493920:
    Magical Explosion should never ever ever ever ever ever ever main deck Diamond Dude.


    Lets set up my SECOND TURN when I am going to FIRST Turn Kill


    Dump a free spell (+1 towards ME's effect, if it hits something you don't want, IE: Hand Destruction, you're 1 closer to what you do want), tribute to summon a Dogma if necessary

    Level 1 YGO Rules Knowledge Judge
    Come join Northern Duel Academy (View profile for Link)
  •  02-21-2008, 3:18 PM 1042167 in reply to 1042114

    Re: Ban List discussion

    You all just made us wait more than half a day for not one change?

    That's disgusting to the people that buy your product. Absolutely disgusting. Thanks for nothing UDE. I was hoping to go to my first regional this time around, and now I would rather quit the game all together. I can honestly now see you have no consideration for consumer opinions...

    The Crystal Beasts are in the board room at upperdeck right now. Carbuncle: "Mwahahah, the time for our tournament revolt is at hand!"
  •  02-21-2008, 3:18 PM 1042169 in reply to 1042161

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1858158:
    And losing Dimension Fusion is another way to kill things off if you're relying on the Valleys.  I'm not saying the deck isn't good (since it's been played before to moderate success), but even with the changes, when push comes to shove, I don't see someone being consistantly lucky enough to pull it off let's see... 30 times to win Costa Mesa?  Figuring on 10 rounds on day 1, and then 5 more on day 2.  The fact that they are cutting to the top 32 is the only thing that might give it more of a fighting chance.  And personally I think the best players will be able to stop it over a 3 round match more often than you think it will be gotten off.


    lol you don't need to be lucky to win with explosion, you need to be lucky to win against it.
  •  02-21-2008, 3:19 PM 1042170 in reply to 1042163

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1885367:
    1493920:
    Magical Explosion should never ever ever ever ever ever ever main deck Diamond Dude.


    Lets set up my SECOND TURN when I am going to FIRST Turn Kill


    Dump a free spell (+1 towards ME's effect, if it hits something you don't want, IE: Hand Destruction, you're 1 closer to what you do want), tribute to summon a Dogma if necessary


    Yes. Hitting a Quick-Play with Diamond Dude is good.

    The deck wins 85% of the time w.o Dude and I would say 50% with Dude.
  •  02-21-2008, 3:20 PM 1042172 in reply to 1042161

    Re: Ban List discussion

    1858158:
    And losing Dimension Fusion is another way to kill things off if you're relying on the Valleys.  I'm not saying the deck isn't good (since it's been played before to moderate success), but even with the changes, when push comes to shove, I don't see someone being consistantly lucky enough to pull it off let's see... 30 times to win Costa Mesa?  Figuring on 10 rounds on day 1, and then 5 more on day 2.  The fact that they are cutting to the top 32 is the only thing that might give it more of a fighting chance.  And personally I think the best players will be able to stop it over a 3 round match more often than you think it will be gotten off.


    Experience actually using it begs to SERIOUSLY differ. And why do you keep assuming that you'll even DRAW Crow FIRST TURN?

    7.5% to 8.3% chance of drawing it approximate presuming you don't draw any Cards 1-4. (Presuming Card 1 = 7.5%, Card 5 = 8.3%). Whereas ME FTK has a 85+% chance of FTKing regardless WHAT it draws. Do you know how much "Stacking" that would require?

    Level 1 YGO Rules Knowledge Judge
    Come join Northern Duel Academy (View profile for Link)
Page 2 of 10 (148 items)   < Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next > ... Last »
View as RSS news feed in XML